For what it's worth, I have the larger VG band and am up to 10CC's in there and still have only slight restriction. I was banded last March and only lost 38 pounds since then. Not sure what that is all about, but I am on my way back to the OCC on February 28th for a check to see whats up. I too wondered if there was such a thing as the band being too big but was assured it was not. However, I do find it funny that after all this time and all these fills, I still only have a slight restriction. I am definitely eating less and healthier that is for sure, but not the tiny amounts the people on here write about. So, hopefully, I will have an answer in 3 weeks.