Lainie,
I was critical at first, as well, but my sister-in-law researched it a lot before having the procedure done five years ago. Her experience was very positive, and just watching her since then and dealing with the stressors and setbacks in my life made me realize that it's time. I prefer going to a surgeon who does the teaching and has had a lot more experience doing the banding procedure. My s-i-l has lost 120 lbs and is still losing. My goal is to lose 85. Also I had a surgery in a So. Cal. hospital by a supposedly good doctor several years ago, and he did a horrible job -- so much so that I had to have the mess undone. All it did was make my condition worse.
I would have been banded by Dr. Ortiz much sooner I think if it weren't for that experience. Nevertheless, I understand where you're coming from.
My best to you, Mary Pat